The Table
What is The Table
Please enter a city name from the list
Please enter a cuisine from the list or leave empty for all cuisines
Price Ranges
aWelcome
cFirst
dThen
bFinally

The Table is the ultimate tool for choosing your next fine-dining experience

We collect professional restaurant reviews and analyze them

Our super-smart algorithm calculates one conclusive score for each restaurant

We display all restaurants in one friendly chart, allowing you to choose from the crème de la crème of the local culinary scene

Discover your next foodie destination

Get restaurant recommendations
from local experts

Please enter a city name from the list
Please enter a cuisine from the list or leave empty for all cuisines
Price Ranges

The Best Italian Restaurants in New York

Open Map
  • Top restaurant
    Details
    ?The Table’s score is much more than a weighted average. Our algorithm also takes into account score trends, Michelin stars, source credibility and critics’ nominal scores.Score
    Review Quote
  • 1

    Marco'sNew York's 16th best restaurant

    295 Flatbush Ave (Prospect Pl)
    Brooklyn, NY 11217
    United States
    (map) (718) 230-0427
    • 87.6
    • ° Buzz Rank
      The Social Score
    • Facebook
    "
    The snug former Franny’s space has been remodeled and is now home to a slightly more ambitious Italian trattoria called Marco’s.
    Adam Platt
    New York Magazine * Read
    Reviews
  • 2

    Charlie BirdNew York's 22nd best restaurant

    5 King St (at 6th Ave)
    New York, NY 10012
    United States
    (map) (212) 235-7133
    • 87.2
    • ° Buzz Rank
      The Social Score
    • Facebook
    "
    “We just want to be your favorite neighborhood joint.” So says Charlie Bird, a new Italian-American restaurant off Sixth Avenue in SoHo
    Amelia Lester
    The New Yorker * Read
    Reviews
  • 3

    La Pecora BiancaNew York's 36th best restaurant

    1133 Broadway
    New York, NY 10010
    United States
    (map) (212) 498-9696
    • 86.1
    "
    What makes this place noteworthy is its all-star team: Restaurateur Mark Barak has already created a bona fide hit with Claudette, and he's brought on Simone Bonelli, who grew up in Modena and worked as Massimo ...
    Sierra Tishgart
    New York Magazine * Read
    Reviews
  • 5

    A VoceNew York's 54th best restaurant

    41 Madison Ave (at E 26th St)
    New York, NY 10010
    United States
    (map) (212) 545-8555
    • 85.2
    • Michelin Stars
      michelin
    • ° Buzz Rank
      The Social Score
    • Facebook
    "
    A Voce is a place where all the rough edges have been conspicuously smoothed away, where the tone emanating from the kitchen isn’t hard rock or haute classical, but low-wattage easy-listening jazz
    Adam Platt
    New York Magazine * Read
    Reviews
  • 6

    A Voce Columbus RestaurantNew York's 63rd best restaurant

    10 Columbus Circle (at Time Warner Center)
    New York, NY 10019
    United States
    (map) (212) 823-2523
    • 85
    • Michelin Stars
      michelin
    • ° Buzz Rank
      The Social Score
    • Facebook
    "
    Late on crowded evenings, A Voce Columbus can turn into a cacophonous happy-hour destination for the legions of business burghers and upscale mall rats in the neighborhood.
    Adam Platt
    New York Magazine * Read
    Reviews
  • 7

    MareaNew York's 64th best restaurant

    240 Central Park S (at 59th St & Broadway)
    New York, NY 10019
    United States
    (map) (212) 582-5100
    • 85
    • Michelin Stars
      michelinmichelin
    • ° Buzz Rank
      The Social Score
    • Facebook
    "
    While Marea is a seafood restaurant, it is not one that seeks to place a divide between that which swims and that which walks. It is perhaps more accurate to call it a restaurant inspired by seafood — but by no me...
    SAM SIFTON
    New York Times * Read
    Reviews
  • 8

    Ai FioriNew York's 67th best restaurant

    400 5th Ave Ph 2 (at W 36th St)
    New York, NY 10018
    United States
    (map) (212) 613-8660
    • 85
    • Michelin Stars
      michelin
    "
    Conservative eaters, who sometimes recoil from White’s offal, lard-heavy approach to life, will appreciate Ai Fiori as a more restrained effort.
    Ryan Sutton
    Bloomberg * Read
    Reviews
  • 9

    EscaNew York's 76th best restaurant

    402 W 43rd St (at Ninth Ave)
    New York, NY 10036
    United States
    (map) (212) 564-7272
    • 84.8
    • ° Buzz Rank
      The Social Score
    • Facebook
    "
    GIVEN all the talk about horse whisperers and dog whisperers, it’s impossible not to wonder: is Dave Pasternack a fish whisperer?...On the evidence of Esca, I’d have to say yes.
    Frank Bruni
    New York Times * Read
    Reviews
  • 10

    Babbo Ristorante e EnotecaNew York's 81st best restaurant

    110 Waverly Pl (btwn MacDougal Alley & 6th Ave)
    New York, NY 10011
    United States
    (map) (212) 777-0303
    • 84.4
    • Michelin Stars
      michelin
    • ° Buzz Rank
      The Social Score
    • Facebook
    "
    You should never expect perfection right out of the gate. But Mario Batali's latest restaurant breaks all the rules: Newborn Babbo is shockingly mature for its age
    Hal Rubenstein
    New York Magazine * Read
    Reviews
  • 11

    SantinaNew York's 113rd best restaurant

    820 Washington St (btwn Gansevoort & Little W 12th St)
    New York, NY 10014
    United States
    (map) (212) 254-3000
    • 82.6
    "
    There were exactly zero restaurants we enjoyed hanging out in Meatpacking until Santina arrived. Now there’s one.
    Andrew Steinthal
    The Infatuation * Read
    Reviews
  • 12

    PoNew York's 117th best restaurant

    31 Cornelia St (btwn Bleecker & W 4th)
    New York, NY 10014
    United States
    (map) (212) 645-2189
    • 82.4
    • ° Buzz Rank
      The Social Score
    • Facebook
    "
    Perhaps Mr. Batali's departure was the best thing that could have happened to Po. Without his full attention, it was able to rest on its association with celebrity. Now, it must stand on its own. So far, so good
    Eric Asimov
    New York Times * Read
    Reviews
  • 13

    Il Buco Alimentari & VineriaNew York's 119th best restaurant

    53 Great Jones St (btwn Lafayette St & Bowery)
    New York, NY 10012
    United States
    (map) (212) 837-2622
    • 82.4
    • ° Buzz Rank
      The Social Score
    • Facebook
    "
    The new Noho eatery doesn't give you anything you can't find elsewhere in the city, but even if your date's a dud, you'll still be charmed by the rustic-chic atmosphere.
    Lauren Shockey
    Village Voice * Read
    Reviews
  • 14

    CarboneNew York's 121st best restaurant

    181 Thompson St (btwn Bleecker & W Houston St)
    New York, NY 10012
    United States
    (map) (212) 254-3000
    • 82.3
    • Michelin Stars
      michelin
    "
    We didn’t know how good we had it. Carbone is here to remind us.
    Pete Wells
    New York Times * Read
    Reviews
  • 15

    SessantaNew York's 132nd best restaurant

    60 Thompson St (Spring Street)
    New York, NY 10012
    United States
    (map) (212) 219-8119
    • 81.5
    "
    If Don Draper had a summer home in Palermo, Italy, it would look a bit like Sessanta, the glam lobby restaurant from prolific downtown plutocrat John McDonald (Lure Fishbar, Bowery Meat Company) inside the Sixty Soh...
    Christina Izzo
    Time Out * Read
    Reviews